Next Project

Responsive Interventions in the Contemporary City

Part 2 Dissertation 2010
Carlos Dos Santos
 Kingston University Kingston | UK
In this dissertation I present a critique of contemporary attitudes to designing the urban realm, through an assessment of alternative approaches in the work of Caruso St John and the Office for Subversive Architecture. The attitude being criticised is the contemporary predicament, originating in early modernism, which in the absence of legitimate cultural imperatives, architecture merely is a process of transplanting forms driven by statistical analysis. In reaction to this prevalent attitude, I explore three possible approaches. The first is a consideration of issues related to the history of place and (collective) memory, as illustrated by Caruso St John’s Stortorget square renovation in Kalmar, Sweden. The second discusses the collaborative Europe-wide collective Office for Subversive Architecture, whose various small-scale projects are subvertive of convention and engage the public imagination. Finally, I look at Caruso St John’s contribution to the Walsall masterplan under the banner of reciprocity – between art and architecture, but also between the architectural artefact and the life it supports.

Disappointed with the abundant fruits of urban regeneration, this dissertation explores my interest in positive smaller scale projects that engage with existing urban fabric, and their potential for substantial transformation through responsiveness rather than imposition. I believe such projects offer legitimate means to intervene in the city of tomorrow more appropriately as they are able to resist over-determination, both of the city’s fabric and its social functions.



This dissertation offers a timely rethinking of the ways the public realm is shaped in the contemporary city. It argues for the need to challenge established attitudes to architecture and urbanism, which undermine public space by prioritising short-term commercial interests and patronising interpretations of the social. Despite its critical stance, the work is positive and optimistic, discussing theoretical attitudes and actual projects that offer convincing alternatives to thinking and making the city. The discussion is historically situtated, intellectually informed and architecturally sophisticated, with the many strands of thought converging admirably, to produce a work of considerable maturity and relevance for our contemporary urban situation.
Tutor(s)
Dr Alexandra Stara
2010
Ville Radieuse, Le Corbusier, 1930 - What remains of the problematic yet heroic 'modern project' is the bare bones of a reductivist methodology, without any of the aspirations.
Typical 'before and after' urban regeneration project in Stepney Green, East London - Expresses a concern for the social but also a token gesture of 'community' - It fails to capture the intricacies and situated nature of public life.
Caruso St John's Stortorget project, Kalmar, Sweden - Stortorget's 'emptiness' resists the determination of urbanism's everyday practice towards spatial coherence by simply introducing program.
'Intact' - OSA's illegal refurbishment of this railway signal box in London, captured the public imagination by expressing an idealised vision of a dream property.
'Point of View' - OSA's simple intervention at the 2012 Olympic site transforms a prohibitive authoritarian structure into an informal libertarian public space.
Figure ground plans of Walsall town centre in 1910 & 2008 illustrate the wasteland induced by de-industrialisation.
The New Art Gallery Walsall - The asphalt pattern extending into the landscape validates the canal & towpath, by introducing order to the dereliction of the town.
• Page Hits: 9766         • Entry Date: 21 July 2010         • Last Update: 26 July 2010